"the Truth at any cost"

Monday, July 27, 2009

Oscar the Grouch and Philosophy




Well everyone, I have made an amazing discovery. Sesame Street set into motion the steps which made me, much later in my life, become a philosopher.
You see, while everyone else was laughing at Elmo's bizarre voice, and becoming accepting of homosexuality via Bert and Ernie, I was intently watching the actions of my favorite Sesame Street character: Oscar the Grouch. (Side note: Grover is way cooler than Elmo.)
How did my affections for Oscar the Grouch manifest themselves later in life? Well, its obvious now! Oscar the Grouch IS Diogenes of Sinope, the cranky cynical Greek philosopher known as the dog. The parallels are innumerable. Let me just lay them out, to prove my point:
Both Oscar and Diogenes are, well, grouchy. Oscar, for one, loves to argue.--what a philosopher. Diogenes seemed to hate people in general.
Oscar lives in a trash can; Diogenes lived in a bath-tub.
Oscar lives and acts unconventionally; Diogenes not only did the same, but it was also the foundation of his philosophy. Diogenes hated custom. Oscar the Grouch even hates Christmas.
Diogenes reportedly walked around in the middle of the day with a lantern--when asked what he was doing, he said he was "looking for a real human being," saying he only could find rascals and scoundrels.
Diogenes lived among dogs and rats. Oscar does as well, living amongst many pets in his trash can, most notably a rat.
Diogenes once masturbated in a public square...well, ok, Oscar never did that. But its a children's show.

The point is, the parallels are to great to ignore. Oscar is Diogenes! Sesame Street is deeper than you once thought.

Labels: , , , ,

Sunday, June 07, 2009

Beating Singer at His Own Game

Peter Singer is one of very few living philosophers who are known in the mainstream--I have seen him on the Morning Show, the Colbert Report, and a BBC news special.
Its probably a toss-up whether he is more known for his animal rights stuff or his ending world poverty stuff, but he is extremely prominent in both areas.
Recently, Singer has published a book entitled "The Life You Can Save". This book is written for a popular audience, and it basically makes the same case Singer has been making since his 1972 "Famine, Affluence, and Morality": that we (individuals as well as governments) should be giving A LOT more money to charities, to end world poverty and unnecessary deaths from things that, frankly, people shouldn't die from-- diarrhea, cholera, etc. etc. Even the poor in affluent countries like the U.S. are much better off than the poor in third-world countries, and proximity should have no independent effect on our obligations.
I generally agree with Singer's project, as well as most of his others (that is, I am a utilitarian who isn't afraid to follow those principles to their conclusion.)

Here, I want to focus on one of his most famous arguments. This is an argument that gets discussed in Intro to Ethics courses all over. Briefly, it is this:

"if it is in our power to prevent something very bad from happening, without thereby sacrificing anything morally significant, we ought, morally, to do it. An application of this principle would be as follows: if I am walking past a shallow pond and see a child drowning in it, I ought to wade in and pull the child out. This will mean getting my clothes muddy, but this is insignificant, while the death of the child would presumably be a very bad thing...the principle takes, firstly, no account of proximity or distance. It makes no moral difference whether the person I can help is a neighbor's child ten yards from me or a Bengali whose name I shall never know, ten thousand miles away. Secondly, the principle makes no distinction between cases in which I am the only person who could possibly do anything and cases in which I am just one among millions in the same position." (Famine, Affluence, and Morality)

Its the example of the child drowning that gets me. I actually think it is an apt analogy--if you can save a child's life by donating $75 to Oxfam, that is just as good as saving a child's life that is drowning in a wading pool right in front of you. That's okay with me. Sure, you might ruin your suit. But saving a child's life is much more valuable than a suit, even a nice one.

But there is an issue here, if we are sticking strictly to our utilitarian calculus (which Singer wants to do). Let's assume, for sake of example, that a child in Africa's minor ailment can be cured with a $75 donation to Oxfam, allowing him to live a productive and full life. Next, let's assume that the suit I am wearing has a resale value of, say, $300. I notice the child drowning in front of me. Here we are, in the same situation which Singer gives above, but with the added detail about the suit's cost. So, it seems we should save the child in front of us--most people would even say its pretty obvious we ought to do that. But let's say I don't have time to take off my suit. If this is so, then, by utilitarian lights, I ought not save the child! Why? Because I can save the lives of 4 children by leaving, selling the suit, and donating the money to Oxfam. The lives of 4 are greater than the life of one, and proximity makes no difference.
This looks to be just another formulation of the trolley problem, or the forced organ-donor example. But it is especially interesting because what Singer says in his work on poverty seems to imply he has to be ok with this counterintuitive conclusion.
Anyone have any way of getting out of this? It sure seems like there ought to be one; that is, I think Singer's argument is cogent--so something fishy must be going on here.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, February 18, 2009

I just may have been right about something

Hey look! Another reason why NOT to get/have a facebook account! Everything you upload or post becomes property of Facebook....forever.
http://consumerist.com/5150175/facebooks-new-terms-of-service-we-can-do-anything-we-want-with-your-content-forever

There is also stuff on the news sites, but I am afraid the links will die, so just google news it.

Labels: , , , ,

Tuesday, July 08, 2008

Religious Freedom

The event that prompts this post is, I'll admit, a bit outdated. Remember that raid on the Fundamentalist Mormon sect (known as FLDS)? Let me recap for a second in case you forgot. A teenage girl called an anonymous tipline to say that she had been abused on the ranch (Yearning for Zion, I believe it is called, if you'd like to wikipedia it). Alright, so that was good, right? She worked up the courage to call out whomever this asshole who abused her was, and hopefully he will be thrown in jail.
But no. Instead, the next day, the powers that be invade the ranch, and take over 400 children away from their families! Because of a phone call?
Think about a regular community, like Traer, or in Ohio like Berea. A girl is abused and calls the proper authorities. Would the police raid every home in the town and take away all legal minors? Hell no!

What I am saying is that I am with the FLDS on that case--apparently the Supreme Court of the state of Texas was, too. One phone call does not warrant taking hundreds of children away from their home. It was, clearly, an issue of religious discrimination. People think the FLDS is bizarre (which it is), and maybe even barbaric, because they allow polygamy, and they pretty openly think men are better than women. Not to mention, they tried to go off and live on their own! How dare they!
Well listen, the fact is, just like freedom of speech, when you have a country with freedom of religion, you have to let the weirdos in.
The state claimed their right to take away the children, because they feared them being 'socialized' to become abusive. The courts rejected this as too broad.

Ok, so thats my opinion on that case. But it brings up some interesting questions about freedom of religion that I just don't know the answer to.
Freedom of speech laws have had many famous court cases to sort how far it goes. Basically anything that isn't obscene (as defined by the Law) is free. But what about freedom of religion? It seems intuitive that we would want a vast range of freedom of religion--but then cases like the FLDS weaken those intuitions. Religious pacifists don't have to fight in wars; this seems fair. Can a religion be openly racist? I would say that should probably be allowed, for similar reasons as freedom of speech. Where do we set the limits? Any suggestions? We can play it safe up in abstract theory land to simplify things.

The second question I have is about organized religions vs. non-organized religions. If the law is willing to grant religious people exceptions from obligations, which they ought to, why can't irreligious people have the same perks? Ok yes, you shouldn't get to avoid draft because its inconvenient, but that isn't exactly what I'm saying.
What I am saying is that, I don't belong to any religious group. But I have ethical standards I take just as seriously as devoutly religious people. Why should I be legally obliged to do something I consider unethical, if religious people don't? And how many members does a church need to have before their beliefs are accepted?
Certainly we can imagine strange religions which would bring serious problems--like a religion which had a compulsory communion of LSD or another illegal substance. The government has let this type of thing go with certain Native American religions; why couldn't a new start-up religion be just as valid?
I'm not asking these questions in order to cheat the system--I'm just trying to consider a principled way to give equal rights to all religious and non-religious people, regardless of their particular faith's popularity, normality, or age. And this question is proving more difficult than I thought it would be. Any takers?

Labels: , , , , ,

Monday, July 07, 2008

Counterfactuals

(I get the idea that, generally speaking, the layperson tends to believe philosophy as an active practice is dead. Philosophy, they believe, is merely the study of the history of thought. And it certainly is. A huge chunk of philosophy is interpretation and study of what other great thinkers thought. But there is actual philosophizing going on today, believe it or not.)

My big project for late this summer and into the fall semester has to do with counterfactuals. What is a counterfactual? Well, let's review some related concepts:
A counterfactual is a type of conditional, of which there are many.
First there is the 'Indicative Conditional':
"If the moon is made out of cheese, then Sally would like some cheese." What makes an indicative conditional true? Well, it is certainly controversial. The common-sense interpretation is that the antecedent (what comes after 'if') must cause the consequent (what comes after the 'then'). When conditionals are interpreted in this way, they are called 'causal conditionals'.
The problem with causal conditionals is that 'cause' is an extremely mysterious concept in any philosophical conversation, and a lot of people think it invokes implicit counterfactuals. This is a problem, as we shall see later.
So for simplicity's sake, most basic, non-modal systems of logic interpret "If the moon is made out of cheese, then Sally would like some cheese," as being logically equivalent to "Either the moon is NOT made out of cheese, or Sally would like some cheese." Logical equivalence means that the truth-value of the first statement must always be the same as the truth-value of the second statement.
Ok, think about this--it takes a moment to grasp.
Now this way of interpreting conditionals works a lot--the only counterintuitive result is that any conditional with a false antecedent is automatically true as a whole. For example-- "If the moon is made of cheese, 2+2=74" is true, because it is logically equivalent to "Either the moon is NOT made of cheese, or 2+2=74," which is true.
There is another way of interpreting conditionals, called 'strict conditional'. This interpretation attempted to alleviate the problem just mentioned by saying only a conditional with a true antecedent AND a true consequent could be true.

Alright, finally to counterfactual conditionals, or subjunctive conditionals (they both refer to the same thing from different literature).
When someone uses a counterfactual conditional, they realize that the antecedent is false, but are trying to say what would be the case if it weren't. For example:
"If Bush had been a veteran, his approval ratings would be higher."
This statement makes sense to all of us, regardless of whether we agree with it or not. But it isn't trivially true or trivially false. So here is the problem--how can we declare its truth-value? We can certainly try to show evidence for or against it--but what evidence is even relevant?
The Bush/veteran case seems to be rationally resolvable, but it seems there are much more difficult cases, such as "If George Bush had been named 'Jeb', the president of the United States in 2003 would not have invaded Iraq." What makes this counterfactual true? If George was named Jeb, it seems our world would be different in ways we can't imagine. Is the speaker saying someone named 'Jeb' wouldn't have invaded Iraq? Or are they saying a 'Jeb' couldn't have won, and Gore wouldn't have invaded? Or Gore would have prevented Sept. 11? There are so many circumstances which we are ignorant of, it isn't clear how the truth value can be determined.
Its also entirely plausible that we just can't talk about situations that bizarre and expect to come up with a decent answer.

But the point and the question in all of this that I am trying to answer is as follows: What is the formal (logical) definition of a counterfactual? Do we interpret them like causal conditionals? Do we consider a world in which all facts are the same besides the explicitly stated antecedent?

This is all very confusing, and I probably haven't explained it well. For that I apologize.

Labels: , , ,

Sunday, February 10, 2008

The Thin Line between Tolerance and Relativism

Though I consider myself a Democratic Socialist, there is something frightening to me about the increasing liberalness of our society. But let me first justify that comment. I am looking at the big picture here; and it seems clear to me that from generation to generation our nation, and most of the world, is becoming more liberal. From emancipation, to civil rights, to near universal suffrage. I mean, our parents generation would have had legal troubles with marrying someone of a different race. That is fucked up. But we've gone a long way. Sure, there are a lot of people who are still against interracial marriage today--but these tend to be older people, raised in a different cultural climate.
Homosexuals will probably be able to get married soon. Who knows, maybe in a few more generations the government will just get out of the marriage business completely. People wouldn't be punished via taxation for their decision to remain single.
But I am happy about all these changes. I've just read J.S. Mill's "On Liberty", and I'm really pumped up about liberalism. I am sure I will be on the liberal side of things for at least a few more years.
So what is it that frightens me about modern society? You ready for this? Relativism.

One of the most wonderful things about living in an industrialized nation on Earth today as opposed to 100+ years ago, besides educational opportunities and 40-hour workweeks (Thank you liberalism!), is our tolerance for those unlike us. No, not everyone is tolerant. And most people aren't tolerant of everything. But more and more people are becoming tolerant of other people who hold different views and live different lifestyles than themselves. This is beautiful! Diversity is wonderful. Freedom is all about living your life as you please--deciding what is best for yourself, deciding what sources you can get your information from, deciding where to work, what to put into your body*, etc.
The problem is that I hear more and more people from my generation faltering. They somehow make the logical gap from tolerance for others to relativism about truth. The implicit argument makes enough sense:
1. I shouldn't judge people for disagreeing with me about what is true or moral, because I don't know any better than they do.
2. But I certainly know a lot about what is true and moral.
/:. 3. So, what is 'true for me' must be different than what is 'true' for someone else.

The problem with this argument is premise 2. The whole idea behind tolerance, as I see it, is that we DON'T know what we think we know. I think that most of us would admit that we probably have some false beliefs. And we would admit we aren't sure which of these beliefs we are wrong about. So, we ought to have tolerance of others based on our acknowledged ignorance. The problem is that people want to have it both ways. They want to be tolerant AND arrogant. They refuse to admit their own ignorance.
Take religion--this is a prime example. Let's say Sally is a Christian, and Sarah is Jewish. Sally is tolerant. But is she tolerant for the right reasons?
The wrong reason: Sally thinks that both her and Sarah have true religious beliefs. She believes Christ is the son of God is 'true for her', and Sarah's not believing so is 'true for Sarah'.
The right reason: Sally realizes that such a deep metaphysical question such as those about religion are unknowable by humanity. She acknowledges that her belief in Christianity is a 'leap of faith', and as such, is fallible. Epistemically, she is in the same position as Sarah, so she respects her differing beliefs.

I see this relativism all over the place. And I see the logical slip that causes it. And its an easy mistake to make. So how can we perpetuate tolerance while retaining absolutism about truth?

Labels: , , , , , ,

Saturday, January 12, 2008

...And now for something completely different.








I have thought about doing this since I started this blog. And I'm in a particularly strange mood today, which means I may remove this post when I come to my senses. Here are some samples of writing I've done in the past 5 years. Notice how it gets increasingly worse over time? Whats up with that? I am old and uncreative.
Don't mind the editing on that first one. Its just too recent to be public at this point (if interpreted correctly)

Labels: ,

Thursday, January 10, 2008

Making Political Philosophy a Science

Ok, so I have an idea, which, though technically possible, is not feasible or plausible. But what the hell, why don't I just throw it out there?
People disagree widely on political philosophies. And I'm talking about the broad picture here, not just republicans and democrats. We've got communists, socialists, fascists, capitalists, anarchists, and many subsets of each of these. Now, despite what you may self-righteously believe, I think there are essentially high quality intelligent arguments for each of these philosophies. I believe, though I'm not certain, that these philosophies ultimately rest on different views of human nature. To take one striking example, capitalists believe humans achieve the most in a competitive society, whereas communists believe humans achieve most when contributing to the greater good. Now that is just one example, of many fundamentally different worldviews. And to my mind, there doesn't seem to be any way to test 'human nature'. But I do have this idea to solve, or at least provide a great amount of evidence for certain political philosophies.
So here is the plan:
We get a bunch of philanthropists and angel investors to give us a TON of money. Billions and billions of dollars. Plus a TON of land. I suppose we could buy northern Canada, where very few people live. Then we get about 100,000 volunteers. Now in my mind, this part would be easy (I'll explain why in a moment). So we divide up the volunteers by their political philosophies, and create like 30 sovereign 'countries' up there in northern Canada. They all start out with the same amount of money; everything else is left up to them. Then we stand back and watch. Give them 50-75 years, and see which societies end up prosperous and which ones fail. Barring any huge oil or other resource find in one of the societies, it seems like a fair deal. Now the volunteer thing would be easy. For the communist country we'd find communists, for the libertarian country we'd throw all the Ron Paul supporters in there, etc.
Again, not feasible. But what better way can you think of to put some science behind our political views? Put real people in a real culture with those policies, and see what happens. Makes enough sense to me.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Saturday, January 05, 2008

What is Modal Logic good for?

Over this break I have been attempting to learn modal logic. Modal logic is the symbolic logic of necessity and possibility. So, for example, its possible that a Republican will win the White House this year. Anything that doesn't entail a contradiction is a possibility. Something is necessary when its denial produces a contradiction--for example: A square necessarily has 4 sides.
So, what is Modal Logic good for? Is it just some garbage made up by philosophers to keep the publishing going and get some professors tenure? Well, yes and no. Modal logic is important to philosophers because a large chunk of the last 100 years of philosophy has been something called conceptual analysis. Conceptual analysis is the attempted defining of a difficult term by its necessary and sufficient properties.
For example, one huge area of this type of work is the conceptual analysis of 'knowledge'. Modal logic helps us to precisely ask questions like "Is it (logically) possible for a person to have knowledge without being justified?", "Is it (logically) possible for a person to have knowledge by accident?" etc. etc.
This work also has certain implications for philosophy of science--are laws of nature necessary? etc.
So I would whole-heartedly agree that modal logic is very important for conceptual analysis. But modal logic is also used for at least one other purpose. Philosophers of mind have been using modal logic in the past 40 years or so to make metaphysical arguments. At first, I didn't even question. Probably the most famous metaphysical modal arguments are Kripke's in "Naming and Necessity". He argues against physicalism in that lecture. I don't want to get into the argument, though its very interesting (and to this day, I am undecided whether I accept it or not. I've gone back and forth for the last couple years). My point is--can modal logic tell us anything about the way the world is? Its hard to believe it could. Modal logic is seemingly a priori. So all bizarre and controversial exceptions aside, Kripke's argument seems to be saying that physicalism is necessarily false in any world with consciousness. And that is a tough argument to make when you put it that way. For I see no inherent contradiction in a physicalist world with consciousness. And I am a dualist, so it isn't just dogmatism going on.
So here is my challenge, to myself, and to anyone who wants to do some preliminary research on modal logic: Give me a simple modal argument which proves something metaphysical. If someone can prove that metaphysics is possible using modality, then I will be more open to the more controversial arguments.

Labels: , , , , ,

Monday, December 10, 2007

Defeat by Self-Refutation

The more philosophy I think about/read, the more evidence there seems to be in favor of the following view:
"Every philosophical position is self-refuting." (Which, if true, is itself self-refuting)
I mean, its just bizarre--maybe its just the way I think, but it seems like every original criticism I can come up with against a view is that it is self-refuting.
Verificationism, for example. "All sentences are either true by definition or only true by appeal to possible experience." Self-refuting.
Naturalism...this is too hard to sum up in one brief sentence. wikipedia it. But naturalism is arguably self-refuting, because if evolution is true, our brains were only evolved to survive and reproduce, not necessarily to reason well. Therefore, our theories don't have any probability of being true, only of being conducive to survival. Therefore, naturalism, a theory created by us, has no probability of being true. Self-refutation.

But I have a new one. I was looking into the 'Brights' movement. The Brights are naturalists. A bright is defined as: "A bright's worldview is free of supernatural and mystic elements." Brights are naturalists. So I'm thinking...am I a Bright? I certainly am a methodological Bright, that is, I don't think science should ever posit mystical entities as solutions or causes of events.
But naturalism originates from skepticism about mystical entities like Gods or spirits. Now I have that skepticism, but I remain utterly agnostic about these entities. Now is naturalism an atheism about these entities? It seems the answer must be 'Yes'--they are the opposite of supernaturalists, who DO believe in the entities. It seems to me the best to withhold judgment on anything of which we have no evidence of. The Brights claim that the absence of evidence is the evidence of absence.
Ok, so what is my point?
The Brights are implicitly holding the Universal claim: "All events in the world have natural explanations/causes." But a Universal claim goes beyond naturalism. It is asserting something beyond all possible experience. It is thus, supernatural. Thus, the Brights are self-refuting.
Unless they are just methodological naturalists; in which case, I am a Bright. But so is everyone but evangelicals. That seems to make the movement much less interesting.

Labels: , , , , ,

Wednesday, December 05, 2007

Aphorisms

If there is one thing I learned from Neitzche, its this aphorism:
1. When you want to make a claim look profound and obviously true without argument (even when its clearly false in any other context), just put it in the form of an aphorism, and people will buy into it.

I guess Wittgenstein also taught me this.

So let me spout off a few aphorisms I developed from the show I went to last night:

1. If you are a true metalhead, when you headbang, you don't nod your head, but shake it back and forth. Why? Because its not metal to say 'yes', and that is what nodding your head is doing. Shake your head back and forth because "No" is much more metal.

2. Watching a local band is like going to Good Will. You will either be pleasantly surprised by finding something awesome, or you will be pleasantly surprised by finding something that is so lame that it is awesome.

3. It isn't 'live music' if there isn't a drummer. Its karaoke by the original artist.

4. 'Disgust for the Weak' is a metal as fuck band name. But the band is not metal as fuck.

5. Being popular with the trendy kids costs you a lot of money. Being popular with indie and scene kids is easier: You just have to say something bad about George Bush.

6. You are only a good live band if every question you ask the crowd is repeated a second time with the preface 'I can't hear you [city or club name]!'

7. When your favorite band goes on at a show and instead of listening and watching them you take pictures of them on your digital camera the WHOLE SET, it pisses me off. So don't do it. One or two pictures, OK. For the memories. I get it. But when you spend the whole set doing it, you clearly don't even like music.

8. Autographs are still stupid. Your favorite band, actor/actress, athelete, whatever--they are just human beings. What do you prove by having them write their name on something?

Dillinger Escape Plan is REALLY good live. And their new CD is great.

Labels: , ,

Thursday, November 29, 2007

Tractatus-Logico Philosophicus

I think I'm finally beginning to understand some early Wittgenstein. He is such a cryptic jerk.
So its like this: I am interpreting him to be saying that The world is a truth-table. (Infinitely long, I assume)

Now I'm not sure if he means that its a truth-table like, thats all there is, or like the truth-table is all we can talk about. I am tending toward the latter. Because Wittgenstein does talk about 'simple objects'. Simple objects are what make up the propositions--propositions are statements about the relations between the simple objects. This is all speculative.
Well we can't speak about the simple objects, only about the relations; I guess.
But the thing is, Wittgenstein never really says what the simple objects are. Atoms? Sense-content? Who knows?

But then its also got this bizarre metaphysical thing going on, which Dr. Baumer pointed out. The world is made up of all possible propositions about the simple objects. (Thats where the truth-table thing came from.) But what the hell are these propositions? Thoughts?
The other bizarre metaphysics is that Wittgenstein talks about the simples as if they were the only possible simples. Every simple object in this Universe is necessary. There are no possible worlds in which any of the simple objects in this world are missing, or in which there are some other additional simple objects. So what these simple objects are is crucial to the whole grounding of his theory. But he never says anything about what these simples are! Atoms? Quarks? Objects? Experiences? Regardless of interpretation it seems bizarre. Not just bizarre, but extremely metaphysical, which goes against the entire positivist project.
So I'm not sure why the positivists worshipped him. Yeah, he wanted to reduce everything to atomic facts. But these atomic facts are so Platonic in nature that its mystical.

(This is most likely all mistaken anyway.)

By the way, the Tractatus is online: http://www.kfs.org/~jonathan/witt/tlph.html

Its fun to attempt to discover what it was Wittgenstein exactly was saying, but at the same time it really makes us philosophers look more like poets. Its like we all are seeking knowledge--if you have a grain of it why don't you explain it in plain language instead of being cryptic and sadistic to all of your readers?

7 - Whereof one cannot speak, thereof one must be silent.

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, November 15, 2007

whoa...

So, now having read Kant, Carnap, Frege, Russell, third wave feminist epistemologists, and now Wittgenstein, I would say...how could it get any worse from here? This has to be the toughest (reading-wise) semester I have ever had. I read the Critique of Pure Reason and the Critique of Judgment in their near entireties (not all of the appendices).
Brutal. But its awesome.
At the same time, I am wondering:
Does anyone fully understand some of these people?
I mean, Wittgenstein...does anyone get it? Or is he just revered because people assume anything that hard to read must be profound? I wonder.

Labels: , ,

Monday, November 05, 2007

Ethicists and Morality

Are ethicists more ethical than non-ethicists?

Some philosopher is doing research on the topic, and so far the answer seems to be 'No.'
Its strange I stumbled across this, because this is something I've always been interested in. I have heard some stories of ethicists doing terrible things, but at the same time, why would you take an interest in something as a career which you didn't want to apply to your own life? It would be like a doctor who refused to take medicine.

Either way, I just thought I would share it in case anyone else was interested.


Also, in personal news, I read 120 pages of the Critique of Pure Reason by Kant in one day--needless to say, I am on the brink of insanity.

Labels: , , , ,

Thursday, October 25, 2007

Health Care vs. Homeland Security

Alright--first, a note for those of you who don't want to read another political entry. I am thinking about learning Esperanto. I have decided to learn it on the condition that at least five other people will learn it with me, so it will actually have a tiny bit of practical worth. Let me know if you are interested.
on to the post!

Alright, if you will permit me to be a cold and calculated utilitarian for a minute, I would like to illustrate why, even if you give them all the benefit of the doubt, given $x amount of money, it would be smarter to put it towards Universal health care than homeland security. But, in keeping with my promise of giving them the benefit of the doubt, let's call it "Socialized Medicine", so they can have the rhetorical advantage as well.

Ok. So. According to the Institute of Medicine, 18,000 Americans died from lack of health insurance in 2002. Now, I take the IOM as being a credible institute (it is non-partisan, and all of their studies are subject to blind peer-review by scientists).
But a conservative may be able to find some reason why this study was biased. So let's lower that number to 12,000. Cutting it by a third seems very generous to me.
Now, selecting the number of estimated Americans who actually died from not having health insurance is giving another benefit of the doubt to conservatives. Because the figures of who doesn't have insurance and why is controversial--illegal immigrants are sometimes included in the count, as well as people eligible for government programs who just don't sign up. But we will ignore the fact that besides flat out death, not having health insurance decreases quality of life as well.
(An interesting analysis of this can be found here.)
Ok, so let's take our next step of helping our conservative friends out. The conservatives may say, "Well, yes. We certainly can agree that there are a lot of uninsured people out there, and the solution is to be found in the private sector." Of course, I am not sure what this would mean. Giuliani is the GOP frontrunner, and he wants to do something with tax credits for the poor. That is not a private solution. In fact, that is is similar to democratic proposals, and as such, we are going to have to call it weak "socialized medicine". Though, his proposal is absolutely unclear, since 'Health Care' is not listed on his website anywhere.
But let's not let it end there. Conservatives don't like Giuliani; moderates do. So let's take a look at Mitt 'double Guantanamo' Romney. Romney's site has Health Care as an issue list, but fails to mention anything besides that health coverage should be provided through market-reform rather than government reform.
Its hard to see exactly what this would be, since he says nothing at all about it. However, I could hardly see it being something other than tax credits.
The problem is, even with tax credits younger adults can choose not to have health insurance, and then just claim bankruptcy if something goes wrong.
Ok though, let's not stop this benefit of the doubt stuff. Let's say these conservative reforms cause half of those deaths to go away.
We are down to 6,000 deaths in an average year caused by lack of insurance. And remember, this is assuming all possible ways the number could be lowered from its original number, 18,000.
Remember that number: 6,000 per year.

Terrorism is a worldwide problem. But in the United States, how many people die from terrorism in a given year? In 2001, 3,000 people died. Since then...none...in the United States at least. But maybe my memory is mistaken. Let's say 50 more die every year. And let's count citizens of the U.S. in foreign countries. About 1,000 contractors have died in Iraq since the war started. Let's just pretend they were all American. And let's say another 50 citizens die from random terrorist attacks across the globe each year. You know, those minor attacks...at hotels and what-not. I admit, I really have no idea about that number, but it seems about right. Hell, call me out on it if I'm wrong.
And, though its quite debatable, and I don't think this is a fair move because these deaths could have seemingly been prevented (not to mention, terrorism is a little rough here because 7 in 10 Iraqis approve of attacks on soldiers), let's include American soldiers in Iraq. As of my last count, about 3838 American soldiers have been killed in the War in Iraq. Let's round that up to 3900. Another 450 in Afghanistan makes 4350.
Ok, I think I've been generous enough. Let's add it all up.
4350 American soldiers
600 random traveling citizens
3000 Sept. 11.
1000 contractors in Iraq
equals
8950
divide that by 6 (years this total makes up)
1491 and 2/3. (average number of American deaths, per year, from terrorism, including American soldiers and contractors in Iraq.)

So, let's look at our raw data:
Being completely generous to our conservative friends:
6000 Americans die per year from lack of health insurance.
1491 and 2/3 die per year from terrorism.

Now am I saying defund homeland security? Of course not. Terrorism is a big deal. What I am saying is this: All Republican candidates (except Ron Paul, who has his own issues) are using fear to try and turn people's attention away from real issues. Terrorism is very frightening. Republicans want people to be so afraid of terrorism that they will vote for whoever will keep them safe from it. But if we look at the raw facts here, rationally, we should care more about a quality health care plan than doubling the size of the military. And on health care, I think it is pretty clear the Democrats win. (After all, if they didn't have the better positions, why would the Republicans downplay the issue so much?)

Labels: , , , , , ,

Wednesday, August 29, 2007

Graduate School... In the Beginning

It is Wednesday...the third day of my studies as a graduate student here at Cleveland State University.
I love philosophy. I am already rejuvenated! I am also already behind on my required reading. But besides my required reading, I have already started a mental list of what I want to read outside of class.
I am taking three 1/2 classes this semester.
First I'll explain the half, because I know that is what you are wondering about.
The 1/2 is part of my assistantship. Since its my first semester, they want me to attend all of the logic courses that I will be tutoring for--I guess so I know what I am in for and am ready for when people ask questions. It looks strangely designed, at least compared to the U of I. At Iowa, we had a 'Principles of Reasoning' course, which was basically recognizing fallacies and basic forms of valid and invalid arguments. Then we had a Symbolic Logic course which was all of the (x)(y)(Fx>Fy)) predicate logic stuff. This course is like half and half. And its arranged on the syllabus that we do the predicate logic before we do truth tables and venn diagrams and stuff. Its weird.
The first real class I am taking is called Analytic/Linguistic Philosophy, which is sort of vague. But judging by the syllabus, it is more of a course on logical positivism (Wittgenstein, Carnap, Russell). My prof was sick for that on Monday, so I'm not sure how that will be.
The second class is Theory of Knowledge, and I think it will be awesome. I don't know much about Epistemology, but its essential problems seem really interesting to me. And I have some prima facie strong opinions about attempts to 'naturalize epistemology', and also contextualism. (I think they are both serious misconceptions). Epistemology is exciting to me because in most areas of philosophy I tend to agree with the majority opinions (ethics, phil of science), but with both epistemology and phil. of mind my views would probably be categorized as 'radical'. I consider this to be good because it makes for the challenge of an uphill battle to formulate good theories. If I can create arguments for my form of interactionism, or my radical skepticism, and these theories can stand up to all attacks, I am in a good position, because in these cases I am arguing against instead of with the leading minds of the field.
The third class is a seminar on Hume and Kant. Fundamental, foundational, necessary. But hopefully it will be fun too.

I love my classes because they are small (12-18 people). There are no strictly graduate classes here, we are in a class with upperlevel undergrads, but I don't think this is bad really, as I once did. It would be pretty elitist and stupid to consider myself smarter than a senior philosophy undergrad, since I was just one like 3 months ago, wouldn't it?
Also, there are only like 10 graduate students here. Isn't that awesome? A small community. I have met 3 or 4 of them, and they seem really cool. Hopefully there will be a lot of conversation between us once I get to know them better. So far its been mostly introductions.

Being in graduate school means something else for the 3 readers of this blog; I won't bore you with politics quite as much as philosophical thoughts. I guess they are both pretty boring, aren't they?
Well, a mixture of different boring elements will be good.
So, expect an entry on skepticism and contextualism in the future, hopefully.

One little piece of news.
Thats the most recent interesting thing I have read.

And hey. I really hate Christopher Hitchens. I really do.

Labels: , , ,

Monday, August 20, 2007

Being an Opinion Leader

I am pretty sure most people reading this will have heard of the concept before, but it may be that I am only familiar with it because of my Journalism minor.
Take any given subject...let's say...movies.
Now I don't know much about movies at all. Less than the average person. So when I want to know whether or not a movie is good, I need an opinion leader. Usually an opinion leader is the leader of several people. For example, Freddie Fillers is my go-to movie guy, a.k.a. opinion leader. But I'm sure there are plenty of other people, ones that I know and ones that I don't, who consider him, whether consciously or not, to be their opinion leader on the subject as well.
Having an opinion leader for things is intuitive. We don't have time to become experts at everything. It seems necessary that I rely on Joe for knowledge about ferrets, and Luke about firefighting, in order that I don't lose my expertise in another category.
On the other hand, having an opinion leader for everything is counterintuitive, at least to me. And this is what upsets me. I see people who do this. They go through life relying on other people's opinions for nearly everything. First of all, how is this living? Ok, that might be a little harsh. But putting your entire web of belief into a network of opinion leaders seems silly, some kind of form of cognitive suicide. Not to mention--opinion leaders are just as fallible as you and me (because, after all, they are you and me). Blind faith in an opinion leader is just dumb. Which is the reason why deciding an opinion leader should be done consciously when possible, because otherwise we could find ourselves listening to someone like Bill O'Reilly or Kevin Trudeau.
The bigger problem here is the giving up of belief-control, subconsciously, to a large group of fallible opinion leaders. And this is the thing I see happening to people I know, and this is what disappoints me. Opinion leaders are a necessary evil. Relying on only them is the bigger problem.
The solution to the bigger problem is to bring your fields of expertise to a conscious level and deciding what things you only trust yourself to form an opinion on. One thing I think everyone ought to become their own opinion leaders of is ethics. This would do a serious blow to harmful and useless social norms. As far as other areas, I would say religion would be pretty huge. Being of a certain religious belief because you were raised a certain way seems like an extremely arbitrary way of deciding your foundational metaphysical beliefs. Other areas of importance are up to you, but it seems like the smartest thing to do would be to become your own opinion leader on as many topics as possible to research.
Which brings me to my final point. The entire need for opinion leaders is that we don't have time to do the necessary research to make an educated decision about everything. So, giving up opinion leaders must come at the price of doing research and thinking about the subjects you have decided to take belief-control of. I am not advocating that people just arbitrarily decide something for each subject and then tenaciously cling to it. Time and thought is necessary as well!
But it seems very worth the research to take back control of one's own opinions, doesn't it?

Labels: , , ,

Sunday, August 12, 2007

Anyone but Clinton Club

I thought it was popular right now to hate Hilary Clinton, but apparently that must be among Republicans only, because she is starting to dominate the Democratic presidential race. Shucks. Just when I'm starting to come around to Obama.
Why do I hate Hilary Clinton? Because she is a woman? No. At least not consciously. Maybe this could become a series of posts I could write about why I cannot stand her. But for today, I'd like to give three reasons why I think it is frightening that she is ahead of anyone in the 'horse race', and why it is clear it can only be because people either a) want to be part of the history of making a woman president, or b) Are not paying attention.
I can't blame people for b). After all, it is early. But when a poller calls you and asks if you are voting in the primary, and you should either say 'no', or say you are rooting for anyone other than Hilary Clinton (and, let's go ahead and say Joe Biden too, because he is in many ways just like Clinton, but as he is lower than Kucinich in the polls, isn't much of a threat).
So why do I dislike her so much? If I don't cite enough examples of the three things I cannot stand about her below, just watch the debates, and you'll see it.

1."Anyone but Bush" --The Democratic party rode off of this in 2004, and yet Hilary Clinton is still applauded over and over again for answering any tough question by saying something about how much the 'current administration' sucks. Yeah, Hil, we know that. Along with this reason goes her basic argument for why people should choose her over the other candidates. Let's see this argument and analyze it:
a. We (the Democratic candidates) are all the same.
b. I'm winning.
c. I am experienced.
Therefore,
d. 'I'm your gal'.
Premise a., plainly false. All Democrats vaguely agree, the war is bad, but each one has their own proposal as to what to do about it. All Democrats vaguely agree on health care, but each one has their own proposal about what to do about it. Everything else, Democrats disagree on, to varying degrees. And this is true among the three front runners as well, so its even false if the premise is weakened to 'The leading Democratic candidates are all the same.'
b. So what? Should I vote for whoever is winning, regardless of whether I agree with them or not? Well damn, then my whole concept of voting is fucked up. I'd better remember this come voting time, if a Republican candidate is winning, I have to vote for them.
c. True; however, you are not the most experienced. That would go to Richardson, Biden, and Dodd.
B and C aren't that mistaken, however, it is A as a premise that pisses me off so much.
2. The lobbyist thing.
Everyone should really watch this video if they plan on voting in the primaries. Edwards challenges Clinton to stop taking money from lobbyists, and she just flat out says 'no, lobbyists represent real people.' (Hilary Clinton was the pharmeceutical company lobby's biggest recipient in 2006).
Although, to be fair, Edwards' hedge fund campaign doesn't seem much better. But at least he promotes public finance of campaigns.
3. 'I stay away from hypotheticals.'
This is what Hilary Clinton says whenever she is asked a hard question, along with, 'well, at least I won't suck as much as the Bush Administration.' What does this even mean, "I stay away from hypotheticals" ? Does it really make people think she is mature or a better candidate because she refuses 'what if' questions?
It is just a way to avoid making any campaign commitments!
Besides, how can you really even run for president, or debate for president, if you really are oppose to answering hypotheticals?! Isn't pretty much every debate question framed in the hypothetical 'If you were elected President..."?
It is such a sleazy question dodge. I know that all candidates dodge questions, but this is somehow worse, because it makes her look 'mature' or 'experienced'.

Most people hate Hilary Clinton because she has changed her views on basically everything except health care. I agree. But I thought I would touch on some of the other things. Please vote for anyone but Hilary.

One final note: There is a new 527 I'd like to publicly support, called "Rock the Debates" (www.rockthedebates.org) and they are basically trying to get all Democratic and Republican candidates to commit to having a debate with ALL candidates with a mathematical chance to win the election.
I think its a pretty good cause for democracy, letting third parties call out the major parties in a debate. It won't happen, but why not try?

Labels: , , , , ,

Tuesday, August 07, 2007

A Paradox of Democracy

So I only have one political philosophy class under my belt, so maybe this is already a dilemma in the field. But I realized a bit of a problem with democracy and the 'rational voter' about a week ago. Hopefully I will explain this problem well enough that someone will have a satisfactory conclusion. Because if not, I will probably just ignore this problem when it comes time to actually make political statements and vote.
Ok--so, for simplicity, let's say that voters are generally rational, but not omniscient. They have two options: a) Vote for what they feel is best for the country (or possibly the world), or b) Vote for what they feel is best for them personally.
Now it seems that most people I've asked think that a) is the best option. I agree. However, we are not omniscient, and in fact, the vast majority of us lack a large chunk of relevant information. We really only go off of our own experiences and what little research we do read in newspapers, magazines, or television.
Let's take, for example, the economy. I know nothing about the economy. Is it true that the tax cuts for the rich stimulate the overall economy enough that it creates jobs? I'm not sure. Maybe. When it is an area of debate to even highly educated economists, how am I to decide what is best? I have to take a leap of faith based on anecdotal evidence, at best. Virtually all issues are this way. Health Care, Education, the war, global warming, etc.
Now if all voters (whom we have agreed are rational and not omniscient) decide to choose option a), it seems like we put our trust too much in what magazines, books, TV, newspapers we read and the selected information they give to us. Don't get me wrong, I'm not crying conspiracy here, I am just saying that we only have so much time to do research, and regardless of which sources we choose for information, it is a limited amount of sources, which taints everything from the start.
So a), although well meaning, would cause the majority to vote for whatever is the most rational choice given whatever information is most widely publicized or read. And this doesn't seem right, unless we assume all relevant facts are widely publicized.

b) is ideal, in theory. If all voters are rational, they vote for what is best for them, and whatever is best for the majority goes. But isn't there something counterintuitive about such blatant selfish voting? For example, I don't know anyone who has died in the war in Iraq. So as a rational and selfish voter, I just shouldn't give a damn about that issue at all? And the Iraqi civilians, hell, I have no chance of knowing any of them, so I shouldn't take that into account when going to the booth?
Should I vote against gay marriage? After all, I'm not gay, and it would mean more of my tax money spent on federal benefits that I am already eligible for.
Should I vote for ethanol? It is great for the economies of the midwest, so shouldn't a rational midwesterner vote for it, regardless of the fact it uses more energy in fossil fuels than it produces?
Should I vote against national healthcare? After all, I have insurance, so I have no worries.
Maybe I have too strong of a conscience, but this just doesn't feel right.

So how do we solve it? I have no idea.

Oh...and they don't have bagged cereal here. Actually, we can't find any generic cereal, aside from ALDI. What is that? Thank God for Aldi.

Labels: , , ,

Sunday, July 15, 2007

I,Songwriter, signing off...

With my band Witness the Undefined playing our last show a week from Tuesday (Thats July 24th, at the Picador at 9PM), I wanted to post a little something about the music I have been a part of creating over the past 8 years in several bands... infandous, Drag For Miles, and finally, Witness.
None of my bands were very successful...infandous got pretty big locally right before I left, but they are even more popular now, and any remnants of influence from me is gone.
I now realize why this is (that I've never been in a successful band). I will probably never know whether I have succeeded in what I wanted to create. Its impossible to judge one's own music. You just can't listen to a song that you have written and expect it to sound anything like it will to someone who has never heard it. When musicians do try to judge their own music, they tend to love it, because they know all the fine details that went into it that no one else will notice (see Billy Corgan).
Some people still have an outlet for whether they have succeeded in what they've done, because they are specifically trying to create a sound that will appeal to a certain demographic, be it pop music or generic metal. None of my bands have been extremely interested in creating catchy or danceable hits.
Witness the Undefined is the closest I could ever have asked for the epitome of what my dream band would be. I can think of areas where we needed improvement (vocals, lyrics, harmonies), but we have done everything I have wanted in terms of writing songs conceptually, and breaking what we see as nostalgic traditions (choruses, 4/4, breakdowns). But our overall goal was to create GOOD music...original, unpredictable, experimental, and obviously emotional.
And this I will never know if we achieved. The problem is that when you are in a band that is intentionally trying to be different, it comes across as bad. Because people want to judge bands in the same way they judge other bands. If person A drives to a Witness the Undefined show listening to Metallica, or System of a Down, they are going to judge us by the same standards as they judge those bands. And let me clear this up: I am not saying 'don't judge us', because yeah, I want you to judge us. And I'm not saying that we need to be held to a lower or higher standard than music on the radio. I am saying DIFFERENT. because bands on the radio ought to be judged by catchiness...ability to get you singing along or bobbing your head. But we don't want to be judged by that standard...we aren't going for that. We want...well, let me just speak for myself. I want our music to throw you off, to make you LISTEN. Its not background noise, and its not nostalgia. And its not shut-your-brain-off-and-sing-along music. It is supposed to hold your attention--and you are supposed to think. As I said, we wrote our songs conceptually, and ideally this would matter to people..but people aren't looking for concepts, so they don't notice it.
I am not talking down to people. I am not saying our music is too high-brow for anyone. What I am saying is that people aren't looking for conceptual. They are not looking for mathematical. So there doesn't seem to be anyone to judge us by that standard...thus, no way for us to know if we have achieved our goal.

I guess it just upsets me if people think our music is weird because we aren't talented enough to write radio hits. Because 1. we wrote a catchy shitty song, and its called 'Deep Drags', and 2. Our music takes way more talent to write and play than any song on the radio.

Come see us! July 24th, its our last show and our CD release show.

Labels: , , ,